Is Andrew McCullough the man to replace Cameron Smith?
Is Andrew McCullough the man to replace Cameron Smith?

McCullough’s not the man for Maroons

WHEN Cameron Smith retired from Origin Andrew McCullough could quite rightly have felt that his time had come, but much as I feel for the guy, I wouldn't have him in my side.

Smith was more than a hooker. He was a playmaker, a defender and a goal-kicker, to say nothing of experienced leader.

McCullough fills the tackler role, but that leaves a lot of other holes, especially with Johnathan Thurston and Cooper Cronk also hanging up the rep boots.

 

I would go with Ben Hunt at hooker. He played there well for the Broncos when McCullough was injured last season, and has worn the No. 9 for Australia.

Having him there allows the in-form Daly Cherry-Evans to come in as halfback and goal-kicker. He is also a field-goal specialist - and captains his club side.

With Hunt and DCE providing two playmakers for the price of one, and both having Origin experience, you come closer to filling the giant boots of Smith.

And if it doesn't work, McCullough could still get his chance in Games ll and lll.

Ben Hunt has had a taste of State of Origin.
Ben Hunt has had a taste of State of Origin.

 

MIKE COLMAN'S QUEENSLAND TEAM

1 Billy Slater

2 Corey Oates

3 Greg Inglis

4 Will Chambers

5 Dane Gagai

6 Cameron Munster

7 Daly Cherry-Evans

8 Matt Scott

9 Ben Hunt

10 Jarrod Wallace

11 Gavin Cooper

12 Felise Kaufusi

13 Josh McGuire

14 Michael Morgan

15 Josh Papalii

16 Dylan Napa

17 Coen Hess

TOUGHEST CALL: Hooker-half conundrum. Feel for McCullough but need more than a tackling machine to replace Smith. Hunt has played hooker for Australia and playing him there allows DCE to come into the side, doubling creativity and providing a goal-kicker and golden point specialist.

Corey Oates was unlucky to be dropped last series.
Corey Oates was unlucky to be dropped last series.

CRUELLEST CUT: Darius Boyd, but as George Harrison said, all things must pass. Have gone for Corey Oates because: 1. You need one big winger 2. He can play in the forwards at a pinch. 3. Still can't work out why he was dropped last year.

ON THE VERGE: Joe Ofahengaue and Jai Arrow. Could be there before series is out but Queensland is about loyalty and Hess did the job last year.



JM Kelly exec grilled about $300k transfer to self, family

premium_icon JM Kelly exec grilled about $300k transfer to self, family

JM Kelly Group financial controller shifted $340k to self, family.

Minister quizzed on impact of Adani for future mines

premium_icon Minister quizzed on impact of Adani for future mines

Adani has been dogged by claims the Carmichael mine will face significant financial...

DCTC has a 2020 vision after AGM

premium_icon DCTC has a 2020 vision after AGM

A full team of executive committee volunteers were confirmed at last week’s AGM...