Vaccination and climate change deniers beyond persuasion

GOVERNMENTS are worried. Vaccination rates are falling under the influence of a campaign of misinformation by a small minority of fanatics.

Scientifically there is no debate about immunisation, with every relevant health authority strongly endorsing vaccination.

But anti-vaccination activists refuse to accept the evidence, claiming that "every issue has two sides".

They believe vaccination is ineffective and unnecessary and that vaccines contain toxins and cause autism.

They seize on the occasional dissenting study and exploit it for all it's worth, even after it has been discredited.

They go hunting for instances of apparent adverse responses among children and advertise them as proof that jabs are dangerous and should be abandoned.

Anecdotes that seem to confirm their opinions trump mountains of carefully collected scientific evidence.

They spread theories about cover-ups, information-suppression and conspiracies among medical experts.

They claim to be protecting our freedom and talk darkly about the government trying to take away our liberty. They portray themselves as David bravely fighting Goliath.

While claiming to have better access to scientific truth, the anti-vaccinators show no respect for best scientific practice and dismiss the established experts as frauds.

The anti-vaccinators attempt to hide their fanaticism behind a façade of respectability, adopting misleading names for their organisations and promoting the views of "experts" who look credible, but who cannot seem to convert their expertise into publications in peer-reviewed journals.

While claiming to have better access to scientific truth, the anti-vaccinators show no respect for best scientific practice and dismiss the established experts as frauds.

These tactics are common knowledge. But every one of them is also used by climate science deniers.

And yet the same kind of unhinged repudiation of an overwhelming body of scientific facts is treated not as the private obsession of a handful of nutcases, but as a legitimate part of the "debate" over global warming.

The media treat the anti-vaccinators with the disdain they deserve, but sections of the media see no contradiction in actively promoting the same type of anti-science fanaticism when it comes to climate.

The Australian recently supported attacks on "political correctness" in the school curriculum, giving voice to a teacher who argued that "there's no Asian way of looking at physics".

Quite so; yet it routinely warns its readers about "left-wing" climate science.

Unhealthy advice

What would we think if Prime Minister Tony Abbott declared "immunisation science is crap"?

Or if he appointed Meryl Dorey, who runs the Australian Vaccination Network (which was recently ordered to change its misleading name), as chair of the National Preventive Health Agency's Advisory Council?

Yet Mr Abbott has appointed climate denier Maurice Newman to be chair of his Business Advisory Council.

In 2010, while chairman of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, Newman told journalists they should present both sides of the debate. Back then he felt the need to restrain himself.

Now unleashed, Newman is in full flight mimicking the anti-vaccinators. Writing last month in The Australian (where else?) he declared that the evidence for human-induced climate change is a "scientific delusion".

Increasing storm damage is one sign of climate change.
Increasing storm damage is one sign of climate change.

Newman professes to believe that the scientific establishment is engaged in "mass psychology" because it is "intent on exploiting the masses and extracting more money" (to what purpose he did not say).

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change - the main global body that reports the scientific evidence on the issue - allegedly "resorts to dishonesty and deceit" and promotes "the religion behind the climate crusade".

Newman insists there are "credible" scientists who say the Earth is cooling rather than warming.

He says that governments that promote renewable energy are engaged in a "cover-up", while state health departments are "hiding" evidence on the health dangers of wind farms.

He declares that unless someone soon puts a stop to this "climate change madness" most of us will "descend to serfdom".

Bizarre understanding

In a sane world this kind of fulmination would disqualify anyone from public office. But not today. The same ravings now issue from the mouths of many politicians who ought to know better.

One wonders how a man with Newman's bizarre understanding of the state of the world can provide the government with sound advice about Australia's business future, particularly when his claims about how climate policies have "decimated" our manufacturing industry have been rebuffed time and time again by systematic economic analysis.

If a private corporation appoints to its board someone with Newman's views then that is of no public concern. But to have such a man in a senior public advisory role ought to worry every citizen.

I'm guessing that Newman supports immunisation and would not recognise in himself the kind of primitive thinking noted by The Lancet way back in 1927.

In an article titled "The Psychology of Antivaccination" the prestigious medical journal commented on the passion of anti-vaccinators in terms that apply with eerie resonance to modern climate science denial.

It noted that the value and limitations of vaccination against smallpox had been thoroughly researched and understood by scientific medicine, and yet it went on to add:

"We still meet the belief … that vaccination is a gigantic fraud deliberately perpetuated for the sake of gain… The opposition to vaccination … still retains the 'all or none' quality of primitive behaviour and, like many emotional reactions, is supported by a wealth of argument which the person reacting honestly believes to be the logical foundation of his behaviour."

The anti-immunisation brigade is still at it, yet giant strides have nevertheless been made in protecting public health.

There is no such luxury in the case of climate change, and it is the anti-environmental paranoia of men like Abbott and Newman, and Andrew Bolt and George Pell, that endangers the health of our planet.

Clive Hamilton holds the Vice Chancellor's Chair at the Centre for Applied Philosophy and Public Ethics at Charles Sturt University. He has written a number of books including Earthmasters, Requiem for a Species and Affluenza.

This article first appeared on The Conversation website. You can source the original article here


Topics:  climate change immunisation the conversation tony abbott vaccination

EXCLUSIVE: More renewables projects in Gladstone's pipeline

NEW PROJECTS: Renew Estate director says the company is targeting a "20 per cent to 30 per cent reduction in energy bills for a typical home in the region.” (File photo)

"Targeting a 20 per cent to 30 per cent reduction in energy bills.”

113 jobs in the Gladstone region you can apply for right now

JOB OPPORTUNITIES: Cr Cindi Bush has compiled a list of more than 50 jobs taking applications right now.

Cr Cindi Bush has compiled a list of job opportunities.

Gladstone graduate recognised at state awards

RECOGNITION: Jasmine Elliott receives her award in South Bank today.

Jasmine Elliott was one of only four regional students awarded.

Local Partners

Cost of having children soaring sky high

PARENTS-TO-BE have been warned that it’s now more expensive than ever to bring a child into the world, and competition among parents is driving up the price.

These are the sex capitals of Australia

Sex is in demand.

Data reveals surprise Australian suburbs where people want sex the most

Aussie couple road tests hotels by having sex in them

Justin and Jess have revealed their steamy hotel experiences.

They won a comp to share stories of getting lucky in hotel rooms

‘I have slept with 100 people’

The documentary is one person’s quest to track down their 100 past sexual encounters

Documentary counts down one person’s full list of sexual encounters

Pregnant Erin Molan hospitalised

Erin Molan has been announced as the new host of the Footy Show. Picture: Jonathan Ng

She collapsed, hitting her head on the ground

Botched jump led to years of hell

Hilary Judith nearly died in a skydiving accident. But that was only the start of the trauma.

Her body was reliving the accident, over and over again