News

Science or spin?

Gladstone Harbour testing shows it’s not “toxic”, however, Erin Brockovich says she is worried about destruction of the harbour.
Gladstone Harbour testing shows it’s not “toxic”, however, Erin Brockovich says she is worried about destruction of the harbour. Brenda Strong

THE fish health saga on Gladstone Harbour has become a celebrity cause, but is scientific evidence drowning in a sea of cliches?

Erin Brockovich appeared on Channel 7's Today Tonight last week to voice her concerns over what she believes is the destruction of Gladstone Harbour by the controversial dredging project.

Ms Brockovich is the celebrity face of Shine Lawyers, which is representing a large group of commercial fishermen in a legal fight for compensation from the Gladstone Ports Corporation.

She has a decorated history of fighting environmental lawsuits in the United States and Shine Lawyers are hoping her support can turn the tide in their favour.

Ms Brockovich's appearance on television did not contain any evidence to back her claims and the program did not provide any response from Gladstone Ports Corporation or the relevant government departments.

Today Tonight yesterday told The Observer they had not sought a scientific response to her claims, because the story was "not an investigation into the harbour dredging".

Instead, it was a story about "a celebrity environmentalist".

Shine Lawyers and Gladstone commercial fisherman Trevor Falzon commented in the show to back up Ms Brockovich's claims.

An Environment and Heritage Protection spokesman yesterday reiterated there was no evidence of toxicity in the harbour.

"The latest water quality sampling is consistent with historical trends, apart from the impacts of the January 2011 floods, resulting in lower salinity levels, which was also seen in other parts of the state," he said.

"The measured water quality parameters and their variation are consistent with expectations for a highly dynamic, urbanised and industrial harbour and port."

 

Joining the fight

Asked what scientific evidence it was relying on, Shine Lawyers said it had gathered a number of affidavits from fisherman, local business owners, scientists and the QSIA in support of the case.

They will also rely on recent findings from UNESCO's investigations into the development surrounding the Great Barrier Reef and "photographic evidence of the diseased marine life".

Shine Lawyers said Erin Brockovich's next trip to Australia would "very well include a visit to Gladstone".

Topics:  erin brockovich, gladstone harbour, media, science, shine lawyers, tv



"Melbourne-like" cafe opens in Gladstone today

ALL HANDS ON DECK: Grand opening of Fresh Fix Café on Goondoon St.

"It's like Melbourne with their lane ways"

"Don't trust indicators”: Driver trainer's message on roundabouts

Candita Hamblin explains why roudnabouts are so problematic amongst Gladstone drivers.

Indicators can't be trusted on some roundabouts.

Local Partners

Lady Gaga confirms Super Bowl show

Lady Gaga

Lady Gaga to perform in coveted spot

Girls actors give emotional tributes to hit show

Actor Allison Williams

Actors farewell smash hit HBO show Girls after six seasons

Janet Jackson's pregnancy is 'best thing'

Janet Jackson

Janet Jackson can't wait to become a mum

Jay Z signs two-year movie and TV deal

Rapper Jay Z

Rapper Jay Z has signed a television and movie deal

Nowhere to Hyde: Matt Nable is Australia's man in demand

Matt Nable stars as Detective Gary Hyde in the TV series Hyde & Seek.

NABLE returns to the small screen amidst busy film work.

Marvel's Luke Cage S1E7: Manifest review

Mike Colter in a scene from the TV series Marvel's Luke Cage. Supplied by Netflix.

*WARNING: spoilers if you haven't seen Marvel's Luke Cage*

Beach-side real estate starts at $85k on Fraser Coast

HERVEY BAY REAL ESTATE: You can buy this townhouse in Scarness for under $300k.

Live your beach-living dream locally.

$40million hotel, shops development project for Mackay

Mt Pleasant hotel and retirement accommodation, proposed at 194-202 Malcomson St.

$40m development to take Mackay to 'the next level'

'Flex muscles': Gladstone suburb drops $120K

BUYERS are scooping unprecedented deals by “flexing their muscles at the table”

Few bright lights for property after mining downturn

The Gladstone Regional Council wants associated LNG companies like Bechtel to be apart of the EIS housing accommodation strategy from the outset of the projects and not mid-way through.

Tannum Sands continues to write its own property success story

Property 200m from ocean selling for just over $100K

BEACHCOMBER PARK: Work has started on a new $19.2 million development at Toogoom.

The estate's developer is offering huge discounts for early buyers.

UPDATE: Former rodeo champ's sale rained out, now back on

Larkhill local Ken Consiglio is having an auction of most of the things on his property.

'People kept showing up and we had to turn them away'