News

Coronial inquest into why tugboat sank, killed captain

The tugboat Adonis, that sank killing its captain, is refloated.
The tugboat Adonis, that sank killing its captain, is refloated. Chrissy Harris

THE tugboat Adonis sank in Gladstone harbour and the question why is key to a coronial inquest being held into the death of Dudley Jacobs that started yesterday in Gladstone.

The captains of the two tugs involved in the tragedy have given conflicting evidence on speed or if one told the other to slow down.

Capt Jacobs, 64, a experienced skipper and Gladstone marine pilot, drowned in the capsize near the mouth of the Calliope River on June 11, 2011 when the Adonis and a second Sea Swift tugboat, Wolli, (contracted to Bechtel) had a water barge under tow.

RELATED:

>> Date set for inquest into tugboat skipper death

>> Union to launch petition calling for inquest into boat death

>> Bureau releases report on Gladstone tug rollover death

In evidence before the Coroner, David O'Connell, the issue of girding was raised where the under-tow barge began overtaking the Adonis causing the tow line to be pulled at 90 degrees just prior to Adonis being pulled over and sinking.

A safety hook mechanism to allow the tow line cable to be dropped if there was a problem had been in the locked position and not released.

Maritime Safety senior investigator Kevin Schinder said a Marine Execution Plan (MEP) was done that specifically outlined what each vessel was meant to be doing.

Anthony Phipps was the master of the tug Wolli at the time of the accident.
Anthony Phipps was the master of the tug Wolli at the time of the accident. Ross Irby

This was not adhered to and instead a line was put over the stern of the Adonis.

Mr Schinder said Capt Jacobs was there to observe Wolli captain Anthony 'Tony' Phipps but had been on Adonis at the time.

Adonis skipper Sean Beardon, said the tug had "quite a tendency" to lean over more than other boats because of its narrow beam.

He said the harbour master had required two tugs in case anything happened to one tug so as to avoid damaging the Clinton wharves.

Mr Beardon said they were travelling at six knots (speed over ground) and he called Mr Phipps three times on UHF radio telling him to slow down but he did not.

He said the Wolli had control of the speed they did.

Mr Beardon said as the barge (on a short tow of 41m) began to come alongside the Ad

Sean Beardon, who was aboard the ill-fated Adonis when it sank, leaves the Gladstone Courthouse after giving his witness summary at the inquest.
Sean Beardon, who was aboard the ill-fated Adonis when it sank, leaves the Gladstone Courthouse after giving his witness summary at the inquest. Ross Irby

onis he had no steering before colliding with the port side of the Wolli and capsizing.

He said Mr Jacobs had been on his ill-fated tug instead of the Wolli because he and Mr Phipps had not been getting on - "Tony was butting heads with Dudley".

Mr Phipps said speed was "not an issue", saying he had not received any calls to slow.

He said Adonis was on "a slack line" when he saw it keep going toward port. He said he had reduced his engine revs.

Topics:  coronial inquest inquest investigation tugboat



How to survive a bushfire in your car

IT SOUNDS like a nightmare, but it can happen.

Eight reasons to join the RFS

SPREAD across 93% of Queensland, the Rural Fire Service has about 36,000 volunteers. And you could be one of them.

What if my insurer gives me grief?

CLAIMING your insurance cover after a natural disaster can go one of two ways. It can be a breeze, or like pulling teeth.

Locals flock for a feed at Gladstone's new Schnitz eatery

Schnitz Gladstone head trainer Holly Smith and store manager Chris Allen.

SCHNITZ has done a roaring trade on its first day in Gladstone.

BREAKING: Fire crews rush to Glen Eden fire

Fire crews are working to control a blaze at Glen Eden.

Fire crews work to control a grass fire at Glen Eden.

OPENING SOON: Burgers and beers at Gladstone's latest restaurant

GETTING THE URGE: Gladstone store and operational managers Chase Williams and Justin Charell gearing up ahead of opening.

Gourmet burger restaurant to open at Stocklands

Local Partners

Brad Pitt bids to keep custody battle private

Brad Pitt will go to court to keep his custody battle private

Sia has split from her husband

Sia has split from her husband Erik Anders Lang.

Amy Schumer thanks Barbie trolls for hateful comments

Amy Schumer is in the lead role for the new Barbie movie

Shannen Doherty's husband is suing for destroyed sex life

Shannen Doherty's husband is suing her former manager

Azealia Banks' battery case against Russell Crowe dropped

Russell Crowe will not be charged with battery

Mel Gibson named Best Director at AACTA Awards

Mel Gibson poses in the media room after winning the AACTA Award for Best Direction for Hacksaw Ridge.

HIS wartime drama Hacksaw Ridge sweeps 6th annual awards in Sydney.

Ipswich City Properties asset portfolio retains its value

Ipswich City Council Administration Building, South Street, Ipswich. Photo: Claudia Baxter / The Queensland Times

New website launched by Ipswich City Council

High profile premier invests in Gladstone industrial facility

Former Queensland premier Campbell Newman heads a group that bought the UGL warehouses in Paget for $10 million.

FORMER PREMIER heads group that's backing Gladstone to bounce back.

INSIDE STORY: The highlights of your $150 million CBD

GRAND PLAN: The highlights of the Ipswich CBD redevelopment and where they will be located.

Work on city heart's radical transformation to begin next year

VOTE IN OUR POLL: Sand mine opponents face serious dilemma

Public meeting for the proposed sand mine at Maroochydore last week.

Coast MP calls on Minister to stop KRA proposal with stroke of a pen

Developer's grand new multi-million dollar estate

NEW ESTATE: This is the only plan revealed by the property developer's new Billabongs Estate in Agnes Water.

DEVELOPER given the go ahead for a massive estate with 149 homes.

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!