News

Deaf community slams rejection of hearing-impaired juror

WHILE everyone has the right to a fair trial, it seems not everyone has the right to serve on a jury, with a Supreme Court ruling last week effectively eliminating deaf people from jury service.

Justice James Douglas rejected a woman for jury duty on the grounds that while she was able to lip-read, she was unable to perform the functions of a juror, as she required the assistance of an interpreter.

The move has outraged Deaf Australia CEO Kyle Miers, a deaf person himself.

"You know we haven't reached any equality yet in the court system," Mr Miers said, with the able assistance of an interpreter.

"We need to have interpreters all the time in a trial (if there is a deaf person on the jury)."

With fears over the process of introducing an interpreter into a courtroom, in terms of swearing in and unbiased translations, Mr Miers argued that was far from a concern.

"They (NAATI-qualified interpreters) have very strict ethics and a code of conduct," he said.

"There's quite a high level of training required before they're able to be in a court-room."

Queensland Law Society president Ian Brown said the decision was fundamentally flawed.

"At the end of the day, discriminating against or preventing people with a physical disability from sitting on a jury simply because they have a physical disability of some sort really goes against the fundamental principles we should hold as a society that we're inclusive for all people," he said.

"What we should be looking at are ways and means of providing technological and other support that would allow a person with a disability, visual or hearing, to participate on a jury.

"It is essentially something that we should and could be doing something more about."

Mr Brown said while there were already measures in place in Brisbane courts to enable physically impaired people to serve the justice system, there were other simple measures that could also be implemented.

"It might include small things like amending legislation to allow a translator to sit in the jury room and to assist the jury person," he said.

SERVICE POSSIBLE: Alan Fort can see no reason why hearing-impaired people cannot serve on juries with hearing instruments.
SERVICE POSSIBLE: Alan Fort can see no reason why hearing-impaired people cannot serve on juries with hearing instruments. LUKA KAUZLARIC

Hearing aids well able to help jurors serve

LOCAL hearing specialist Alan Fort has helped change the lives of many Gladstone residents who are either deaf or hearing impaired.

He believes that while a clinically deaf person may have difficulties with serving on a jury, there was no reason why hearing-impaired citizens could not do their bit for the justice system.

"If they're deaf then you can only use sign language and translate; you'd have to think that would be extremely difficult," he said.

"Clinically I think there's no reason why someone with hearing aids couldn't serve on a jury."

The audiometrist said clarity was one of the main problems that could arise with hearing-impaired and deaf people in jury service.

"Basically it's about clarity," he said. "They might hear people talking about a ship and think it was a wish, but hearing instruments can fix that.

"Lecturers, students in schools, they have a small FM system in their ear and the judge could wear a remote microphone that feeds into the small radio system.

"We've got very prominent people in Gladstone using hearing instruments."

Topics:  deaf hearing impaired supreme court



Foodies' scavenger hunt: are you up for it?

IF YOU want to give your tastebuds the flavour sensations of a lifetime, here is the ultimate foodie’s scavenger hunt through Brisbane.

5 minutes with Israel Folau on footy, life and love

Israel Folau and Silver Fern netballer Maria Tutaia announced their engagement last last year.

WE CAUGHT up with football star and Brisbane ex-pat Israel Folau.

10 reasons to head to South Bank this summer

Head to the only inner-city beach in Australia!

South Bank has a ridiculous amount of fun things to do.

Five mammoth events you need in your life

No Caption

BRISBANE isn’t known for doing things by halves…

How to make your child's every dream come true...

Take a dip at South Bank in the inner-city beach.

‘I DON’T want to do fun things, Mum and Dad’… said no child ever!

How to do Eat Street the right way

Know where to start and where to end to avoid a huge food coma before you get to experience all the goodies!

EVERY Friday and Saturday night, Hamilton comes alive.

You can do WHAT in Brisbane?!

Talk about arriving in style! Take your pub crawl to the next level with a helicopter!

BET you didn't know you could do these things in Brisbane...

'Not a pipe dream': Man wants to launch rockets from a Gladstone island

HOUSTON WE HAVE LIFT OFF: John Moody needs $2 million from the council to get his space centre off the ground.

Could Gladstone tap into new $6 billion industry?

'Refused': State MP says smelter had "ample” time to save jobs

Gladstone MP Glenn Butcher pins a white ribbon on Boyne Smelters General Manager Joe Rea at a community function.

Glenn Butcher says BSL were "rolling the dice” for past two years

Local Partners

GALLERY: Goondoon Street beginning to look great

Stage one of the Goondoon Street upgrade is almost complete.


New Year New Yard

Win $1000 Bunnings Voucher
Learn More

Puppetry of the Penis secrets revealed ahead of show

The famed Puppetry of the Penis is coming to the Sunshine Coast for shows in Noosa and Caloundra.

WARNING: This interview contains adult themes and traces of nuts

Noll meltdown won't affect Gympie Oz Day concert

Shannon Noll

Photo Contributed

Shannon Noll is still expected to perform in Gympie next Thursday

11 huge events coming to Gladstone in the next 6 months

Events coming up in Gladstone in 2017.

Your guide to exciting events coming to the Gladstone region

Matthew McConaughey wrongly used as medical example

Doctor tried to steal credit for McConaughey's hair treatment

J.K. Rowling writes through severe back pain

An aching back couldn't stop J.K. Rowling catching inspiration

Elsa voice actor's son hates Frozen

Idina Menzel's son "hates" his mother's most famous film 'Frozen'

Chrissy Teigen likes her "soft" stretch marks

Stretch marks are no problem for Chrissy Teigen

Naomie Harris in the dark over Daniel Craig's future as 007

Naomie Harris has no idea if Daniel Craig will be returning as 007

Songs that get Gladstone 'hot, sweaty and wild'.

Cold Chisel concert at Stockland Park, Kawana.
Photo: Brett Wortman / Sunshine Coast Daily

What song gets Gladstone people "hot, sweaty and wild”?

By the water's edge

Secure your seachange

Gladstone market's confidence coming back for 2017

Core Logic property statistics reveal the region's median house price dropped 16.7% to $275,000 in the September quarter.

Region's median house price drops 16.7% to $275,000

HOT PROPERTY: Money to spend on land, buildings

File picture.

Sale, leasing of industrial real estate picks up in Mackay

Collapsed Coast company could owe up to $5 million

Staff, ATO, landlords among those out of pocket.

Ipswich block of dirt sells for $582 a square metre

JUST SOLD: A property on the Brookwater golf course sold for a record-breaking $612,000.

Property smashed 2007 record by close to $100,000

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!