No payout for man who broke leg being kicked out of hotel

MATHEW Jason Carlyon lists his source of employment on Facebook as "anyone who is paying", but it certainly won't be Gladstone's Queens Hotel after he lost a long-running Supreme Court battle this week.

Breaking a leg turned out to be anything but good luck for Carlyon, who sustained the injury as he was kicked out of the hotel six years ago.

He was seeking almost $300,000 to cover medical bills and income loss.

Justice Ann Lyons said Carlyon's injuries did not appear to be the fault of security guards.

Instead, she said, Carlyon's resistance as he was being escorted from the premises by a bouncer on May 9 caused them both to fall down the front steps.

The bouncer landed on him.

"I am not satisfied that the plaintiff has established that the stumble, trip or fall was significantly contributed to by the actions of the employees," Justice Lyons told the court.

The court heard Carlyon had already consumed an estimated 20 rum and cokes over eight hours.

"I consider on the balance of probabilities that the force used was reasonable and necessary."

Simon Richardson, general manager of Town and Country Pubs, the umbrella licensee of Queens Hotel, said the group was "totally satisfied with the result".

The Observer understands Carlyon, a client of Chris Trevor and Associates, does not intend to appeal the judgement.


Topics:  damages editors picks payout supreme court

NEW: 10 best places to rent in Gladstone between $100-$200

House 8 Gladstone

Here's a list of some of Gladstone's best places to rent under $200

Gladstone's best teacher revealed

CLASS FAVOURITE: Shelley Slade, head of special education services at Gladstone State High School, was named by Observer readers as Gladstone's favourite teacher. Pictured with students Kody Walsh, 13, and Phoebie Walker-Woodrow, 15.

The Observer put the call out for Gladstone's best teacher

60-yo man taken to hospital after nasty snake bite surprise

A Boyne Island man in his 60s was taken to hospital early this morning after suffering a snake bite at his Katandra St home.

Paramedics responded to the call at about 4am.

Local Partners

January Jones: Take time away from your phone

January Jones needs time away from her phone

Mel C won't return to Spice Girls for daughter

MEL C is adamant she won't reunite with the Spice Girls

60's British rock legends to return to Australia

The Troggs will play a string of dates across Australia in November.  Photo Contributed

We all remember 'Wild Thing' and now you can hear it live.

Depp jumps ship from agency of 25 years

Johnny Depp has signed to CAA after 25 years with the United

Orlando Bloom 'buried' Katy Perry in birthday flowers

Orlando Bloom "buried" Katy Perry in flowers for her birthday

MacBook fires up: New "touchbar" will include emojis

COULD emojis help the MacBook again deliver a laptop revolution?

Investors eye new local estate with dirt cheap property

A new estate, Aquatic Vista, has opened at Agnes Water.

BUYERS to go crazy for an entire new estate put on the market.

Want to own one of Australia's best restaurants?

TOP GONG: Mooloolaba Spice Bar has been named in TripAdvisor's Top 10 Australian restaurants for 2016.

Here's your chance to pick up one of the Coast's favourite eateries

OPINION: Banks fear Gladstone future: Councillor

REGIONAL Queensland deserves a helping hand on housing.

Bank reclaims Goondoon St complex plan, places on the market

Multi-million dollar development plan up for sale.

MULTI-MILLION dollar plan for Goondoon St complex on the market.

Tough times in CBD: Woolies says goodbye Ipswich

Woolworths in the Ipswich Mall.Photo: Rob Williams / The Queensland Times

The last day of trading will be January 1

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!