Business

ATO benchmarks trap little guy

TAX TIME: The Australian Taxation Office’s rules and regulations reportedly makes Australian tax the most complex system in the world, and can cause small business owners quite a few headaches.
TAX TIME: The Australian Taxation Office’s rules and regulations reportedly makes Australian tax the most complex system in the world, and can cause small business owners quite a few headaches. File

WHEN I studied tax law in the late 60s or early 70s, it was the old 1936 Act as amended and was at most three-quarters of an inch thick.

A night's reading!

Now, I'm told it's 13,000 pages long - and that doesn't include the case law, ATO determinations, ATO warnings, ATO ruminations and various other examples of ATO verbal diarrhoea.

It's now reputedly the most complex in the world. And it's getting worse.

I have been known to describe it as a cut and paste job, a patch job on legislation that is seldom drafted well enough to enforce its initial goal.

The result is a complex mish-mash of draconian laws, varied and/or qualified by sub-texts whose intention is to stop leakage by people cleverer than the public servants charged with drafting the stuff.

My senior staff each year attend a seminar conducted by the National Tax and Accountants' Association.

It gives us an insight into what the legislators and the ATO heavy hitters are getting up to.

The days when ATO auditors got off their ergonomic chairs and actually wandered the streets looking for the signs of tax avoidance are over.

We are in the "matching" era, the era of cross-referencing. Here's a couple of things affecting businesses that you and your accountant may be unaware of.

The ATO has a long, long history of trying to kill the cash economy, the situation where businesses do not declare their true income.

The trend now is that they assess businesses' declared income against what is called the "industry benchmark" and arbitrarily issue an amended assessment to those who fall outside, challenging the business to prove that their declared income was correct. The worrying thing for business is that the courts are supporting the ATO's approach.

Their argument is that the tax system is a self-assessment system so the onus of proof falls on the taxpayer; if the taxpayer declares a certain income, he should have the paperwork to support its credibility.

My firm has software that tells us whether a business is in peril of failing the ATO benchmarking test. Forewarned is forearmed, while I'm in the mood for clichés.

Crooks do not have my sympathy and I encourage the ATO to chuck the book at them.

The problem is that innocent people who don't conform with what the ATO sees as sacrosanct benchmarks will have to spend valuable time defending themselves against what really boils down to nebulous numbers.

Another example of the ATO using its huge data resources to trap taxpayers is their accessing loan applications.

You guessed it, if you declared a certain level of income in a loan application and that is not matched in your tax returns, you have every right to be concerned.

The ATO is issuing amended assessments which reflect what you told the financier and I'm sure the courts will support them on the same basis - that our tax system is a self-assessment system.

We had a recent experience in our Caboolture office where a small business client was audited. Rather naively I thought, the auditor went about matching bankings with her records which, in this case was a simple cashbook. Why naively? Because true ripper-offerers are never going to bank their ill-gotten gains.

The system really is all about trapping the small players. History shows that they are much more likely to surrender than the big guys with access to highly expensive accountants and lawyers.

Topics:  ato, bob lamont, opinion, taxes, tax time




Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

'All I heard when my baby cried was ‘you’re a terrible mum'

APN Hey Mummy Feature for online - stock images of Katie Dykes. Photo Marc Stapelberg / The Northern Star

KATIE'S battle with PND is not unlike many mothers.

'I just thought all mums got no sleep'

MELTOPIA battled PND with all four of her children.

4 survival tips for mummas heading back to work

The few reminders every working mum needs to read.

Health and nutrition with kids - how do you balance it?

HOW important is health and nutrition in your household?

Smack or no smack - where do you stand?

THE debate is reignited - is smacking acceptable?

Technology and kids: Do you ever cut their wi-fi?

Check out our new video series featuring mums having a chat

AUSTRALIA VOTES 2016: Marriage equality a key issue today

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull visits the Macadamia Processing Company at Alphadale with Page MP Kevin Hogan and Deputy Barnaby Joyce.

It's the age of the social media election

One went missing, the other is dead: 3 year mystery solved

Joan Wallace was distraught at the disappearance of her beloved pup, but now, they will be reunited

SHE went missing 3 years ago, but Indy was returned just hours ago.

WHERE TO VOTE: Polling booths in the Gladstone region

Where you can vote in the Saturdays election. Photo Christopher Chan / The Observer

Your guide to where you can cast your vote this weekend

Latest deals and offers

Ken O'Dowd at Tannum Sands State High

Federal member for Flynn Ken O'Dowd is campaigning for a third term. Photo Paul Braven / The Observer

Flynn candidate Ken O'Dowd tells what the campaign has been like and how he enjoys...

Labor candidate Zac Beers

Flynn's Labor candidate Zac Beers is at the Tannum Sands State High School.

Liz Cunningham Park - Bruce Gibbs

Liz Cunningham Park - Bruce Gibbs

Burnett Heads housing development approved

COUNCIL APPROVED: A Burnett Heads housing development has been approved by Bundaberg Regional Council. Photo Contributed

Councillors approved the development seven votes to four

Three bedroom, 1100sqm block: Is this Qld's cheapest home?

BARGAIN BUY: Is this North Bundaberg property the cheapest home in Queensland?

Becoming a real estate mogul is all about risk and reward