Business

Fears for Arrow as analyst says new LNG plants cost double

ARROW LNG may not go ahead as a standalone project, with an analyst working with Arrow saying Australian projects could halve their costs if they join current projects rather than build new ones.

Deloitte analyst Geoffrey Cann could not comment specifically on the $17.4 billion Arrow project proposed for Curtis Island, that the high cost of labour and the threat of competition from the US meant "brownfield" expansion was the best option for the sector.

Analysts have speculated that gas from Arrow's coal seam gas fields in the Surat and Bowen Basins could make its way into an expansion of one of the existing Curtis Island projects rather than Arrow building an entirely new plant.

"The biggest opportunity for Australia's onshore plants is in brownfield expansions and de-bottlenecking," he said.

The Gladstone LNG industry is already hard at work to alleviate those bottlenecks, as demonstrated just last week by the deal struck between APLNG and GLNG.

The two project players signed off on an agreement to share a coal seam gas pipeline from south-west Queensland to Curtis Island, meaning savings for both players.

Despite the best efforts of the local industry, new Australian LNG projects are still viewed as expensive by the big multi-nationals holding the purse-strings.

Mr Cann said Australian "greenfield" projects (or projects from scratch) were currently running at about $1500 per tonne of LNG produced.

By contrast, proposed projects in the US are running at about $600 to $900 per tonne.

"Australian projects in general are seen as some of the most expensive in the world right now, and there's really nothing on the horizon to suggest that costs are about to come down," Mr Cann said.

He said that costs associated with Australian brownfield projects, however, would be "more or less" on par with their US counterparts.

He said the main cost imposts on greenfield projects was needing to build infrastructure from scratch and the cost of labour.

According to consultancy Hays, the average oil and gas worker in Australia took home an average of just over $174,000 in 2012, compared with figures of $126,400 for workers in the US.

Mr Cann said the high cost of labour combined with lesser productivity in Australia compared with the US did not make good reading for any body trying to build a new project in Australia.

"So Australia's a good solid 20% to 25% higher than North American wage rates, which would be okay if we had 25% greater productivity, but we simply don't," Mr Cann said.

Arrow could not comment before deadline.

Read more: Full interview this Saturday in The Observer's Weekend section.

Topics:  arrow energy, coal seam gas, curtis island, gladstone industry, lng




7 Gladstone jobs up for grabs right now

There are two jobs up for grabs at Heron Island.

Ever wanted to live and work on an island?

600 Gladstone, Rockhampton locals find jobs in a month

Photo Luka Kauzlaric / The Observer

FRESH signs Gladstone is starting to level out after dramatic fall.

'Evasive action': Qantas landing scare at Gladstone Airport

SLOWDOWN: Passenger numbers at Gladstone Airport are expected fall dramatically in the next 12 months.

A QantasLINK plane diverted on landing

Latest deals and offers

Gladstone couple's spontaneous Gympie Muster wedding

Craig Oglesby and Brenda Strong celebrate their wedding at the Gympie Muster with punters in front of the Main Stage.

The Gympie Music Muster was the perfect place for a wedding.

Australian Survivor's Peter: I'm no quitter

Australian Survivor contestant Peter Fiegehen.

ILLNESS forces castaway's early exit from Samoa.

Diva's sister on soliciting charge

FILE - In this May 14, 2016 file photo, Mariah Carey attends the 27th Annual GLAAD Media Awards, in New York. Carey will appear on the Oct. 5 episode of the Fox series, \"Empire,\" the network confirmed Monday at a TV critics bi-annual press tour. (Photo by Charles Sykes/Invision/AP, File)

Mariah Carey's sister has been arrested on charges of prostitution.

Tom Cruise private jets his gym kit around the world

Tom Cruise

Tom Cruise charters private to take his gym kit around the world

Movie behind Depp and Heard split to be released

Soon you'll be able to see the movie that ended the marriage

Bindi's boyfriend helps release huge croc

Chandler (far right) helped the jump team.

Chandler Powell helps catch Duncan the croc

Palm Lake Resort set to move in to Coast with 276 villas

Palm Lake Group has been given approval by Sunshine Coast Council to build a 276-villa over 50s resort and 120-bed aged care facility at the intersection of Caloundra Rd and Caloundra Mooloolaba Rd in Little Mountain.

New facility planned for Caloundra Rd

Warning for unit investors with price plummet prediction

The warning signs are flashing for one real estate sector in 2017 despite others performing the best they have in years and it's not going to be pretty.

One real estate sector looks set for a rocky 2017

REVEALED: Pat Rafter's $18m Coast house on the market

Check out the photos of the Coast's most expensive property for sale

The "correction we had to have" in Gladstone's rentals

UPWARD MARCH: The rental vacancy rate in Gladstone has improved for the first time in more than a year, providing a confidence boost in the market.

Vacancy rates improve with signs that things are getting betterF

ISLAND FOR SALE: Cheap Fraser Coast island drops price again

Suna Island in the Great Sandy Strait will be auctioned by Ray White Hervey Bay on Saturday morning.

This is the cheapest island you will find for sale in Australia

How a family home can fit on a 250sq m block

This is what you can build on 250m2.

Here's the floor plan of a home built on 250sq m